Arab League ambassador: Patriarch Pizzaballa ‘not necessarily’ well received

(The Pillar. Filipe D’Avillez).

An Arab League ambassador said this week that Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem Pierbattista Pizzaballa has “not necessarily” been well-received by Arab Christians in the role that he has occupied since 2020.

“There are different opinions, but I think we would have preferred to have an Arab prelate,” said diplomat Malek Twal, the ambassador of the Arab League in Spain.

He told The Pillar that while Pizzaballa “tried at the very beginning” to serve as a mediator in the current conflict in the Middle East, his efforts were “without any concrete results.” 

Pizzaballa was appointed by Pope Francis as Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem four years ago. The role, which serves Latin Rite Catholics in Cyprus, Jordan, Israel and Palestine, had previously been held by Archbishop Fouad Twal, uncle of Malek Twal, who retired in 2016. 

Before his appointment as patriarch, Pizzaballa had spent years working in the Holy Land, including most recently as apostolic administrator of the patriarchate he currently heads.

Shortly after the mass-casualty terrorist attacks on Israel on October 7 last year, Pizzaballa made headlines by saying he was willing to take the place of Israeli hostages being held in Gaza by the Islamist group Hamas.

Continue reading …

Cardinal Hollerich and synodal inevitability

(The Pillar. Ed Condon)

The relator-general of the global synod on synodality, Cardinal Jean Claude Hollerich, backed this week the incremental and “tactful” progress towards the ordination of women to the priesthood.

The cardinal, who is also Archbishop of Luxembourg, was appointed by Pope Francis to oversee the collection and synthesis of discussion and responses during the multi-year synodal process, due to reconvene in Rome in October.

Hollerich’s call for “patient” discussion towards women’s sacramental ordination runs contrary both to Francis’ affirmation that such ordinations are impossible and that the synod should not be treated as a venue for debating doctrinal change.

But if Hollerich is allowed to continue uncorrected in his role, many might question the integrity of the entire synodal process — and even the pope’s sincerity about his intentions for it.

Speaking to the official media portal of the Swiss bishops’ conference May 17, the cardinal from Luxembourg said that the campaign for the sacramental ordination of women needed to show some “tact and patience” if they wanted to see “real solutions.”

Continue reading …

Washington bishops vs. state AG: Who has a point?

(The Pillar. Ed. Condon).

The Washington state attorney general is seeking a court order to enforce a sweeping subpoena of Church records from the state’s three dioceses, claiming the bishops are obstructing an investigation into historical instances of clergy sex abuse.

The Archdiocese of Seattle and the Dioceses of Spokane and Yakima have issued blunt responses, insisting the AG is acting unconstitutionally and has rejected good faith offers to cooperate.

Washington is the twenty-third state AG’s investigation into Catholic dioceses, and similar investigations elsewhere have generated pushback from bishops, Church officials and lawyers — including allegations of political targeting of the Church, unconstitutional behavior, and political posturing. 

But in other instances, those investigations have also led to the painful uncovering of decades of mishandling of cases, cover ups, and major settlements for victims.

Continue reading …

‘Close to the wounds of Jesus’ — Survivor, advocate aims for Church’s healing

(The Pillar).

Teresa Pitt Green is a survivor of clergy sexual abuse.

She is an advocate for abuse survivors, an expert in restorative justice, and a witness to the harm of clergy abuse, and the possibility of healing.

Pitt Green is a co-founder of Spirit Fire, which “is a fellowship of survivors of abuse within the Church who share, as part of our ongoing recovery, a spiritual practice which permits us to offer our wisdom, experience, and faith to all others who seek healing, growth, and reconciliation in the wake of the abuse of children and vulnerable adults in a faith setting – in particular in the Catholic Church,” according to the group’s website

In November 2018, she addressed the U.S. bishops’ conference, during a prayer service in the wake of the Theodore McCarrick scandal. 

“This is my story,” she told the USCCB. “Long ago — five decades ago — where the innocence of childhood was entrusted to the holiness of priests, evil struck. And that wounded relationship — that ruptured relationship — has yet to heal.” 

Continue reading …

Why Pope Francis is meeting the new Syro-Malabar leader

(The Pillar. Luke Coppen).

Major Archbishop Raphael Thattil met with Pope Francis Monday for the first time since his election as head of the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church in January.

The meeting was a chance for both men to take stock of developments in the largest of the 23 Eastern Catholic Churches in full communion with Rome after the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church.

In an almost 1,500-word address to Thattil, his brother bishops, priests, and Syro-Malabar laity, the pope tackled the most sensitive issue in the Eastern Church: the decades-long dispute over its Eucharistic liturgy.

He also made a surprise announcement concerning the ever-growing number of Syro-Malabar Catholics living outside of the Church’s homeland of India. 

Continue reading …

Pope Francis and the ‘Metropolitan Model’

(CARINO HODDER. The Pillar).

Pope Francis’ motu proprio Vos estis lux undi turns five years old this month. 

First promulgated for an experimental period of three years and now in permanent force, the letter delegates the Holy See’s power to investigate Church leaders who have no superior other than the Pope himself – chief among them diocesan bishops – to a metropolitan archbishop, in cases where that Church leader has been accused either of sexual abuse or of mismanaging abuse cases.

Continue reading…

Catholic leaders press for Orthodox Easter Ukraine war prisoner swap

(LUKE COPPEN. The Pillar).

Catholic leaders are pushing for a major exchange of Ukrainian and Russian prisoners of war ahead of Orthodox Easter this Sunday.

Pope Francis launched the push March 31, when he called in his Easter “Urbi et Orbi” message for “a general exchange of all prisoners between Russia and Ukraine: all for the sake of all.” 

Continue reading…

UK ordinariate’s first bishop is ‘vote of confidence’ from Rome

(The Pillar).

The ordinariate for former Anglican clergy and lay Catholics in the UK will have its first bishop leader, the Vatican announced Monday.

Fr. David Waller will become the Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham’s second ordinary, and its first bishop. 

Waller’s appointment, like his pending consecration as bishop, signals the English ordinariate’s growing stability after more than a decade of existence, and is a “vote of confidence” from Rome, according to a senior priest of the ordinariate. 

Continue reading…

The impossible synodal debate on ‘deaconesses’

(The Pillar. ED. Condon).

A Vatican synod official raised again this week the possibility of female deacons being introduced into the Church in an interview with a German Catholic newspaper. 

In an interview with the German publication Die Tagespost, synod undersecretary Sr. Nathalie Becquart said that the introduction of female deacons on a regional basis was “a possibility” following the synodal process.

Continue reading…

The complicated future of Nicaraguan bishop appointment

(The Pillar – Edgar Beltrán).

On March 7, Cardinal Leopoldo Brenes, archbishop of Managua, turned 75 – the age at which bishops are required to present their resignation to the pope.

The cardinal’s birthday escalates an already uncomfortable episcopal situation in Nicaragua.

With barely 7 million inhabitants, Nicaragua’s episcopal conference is made up of just nine dioceses, including the archdiocese of Managua.

Of the nine, at least five are in an irregular episcopal situation.

Continue reading…

Why India’s bishops want to get out the vote

(The Pillar – Luke Coppen).

When Catholic bishops issue pre-election messages in Western countries, they often limit themselves to general remarks about the importance of voting for the common good.

But when Cardinal Filipe Neri Ferrão issued advice April 15 ahead of India’s general election to Catholics in his Archdiocese of Goa and Daman, he was very specific.

Continue reading…

Financial crimes trial witness named supreme court prosecut

(The Pillar. Editor´s ).

In a surprise move Wednesday, Monsignor Alberto Perlasca was reappointed as a prosecutor at the Church’s supreme canonical court. Perlasca was the often controversial key witness for the prosecution in the landmark Vatican financial trial, which concluded last year.  As first reported by the tabloid site Dagospia and confirmed by The Pillar, the court was informed of Perlasca’s reappointment in a letter from Secretary of State Cardinal Pietro Parolin on 16 April. 

Continue reading

DC Knights call for Rupnik art removal

(The Pillar. MICHELLE LA ROSA).

The Cardinal O’Boyle Council 11302 passed a resolution April 9 calling on Knights leadership to remove Rupnik’s artwork from the shrine’s Redemptor Hominis Church and the Luminous Mysteries Chapel. The resolution notes that Rupnik has been accused of sexually abusing religious sisters in the context of creating his works of art.

Continue reading

Bishop’s former secretary claims ‘hush money’ payments made to alleged victims

(The Pillar).

The former secretary of an Australian bishop charged with sexual abuse told The Pillar that she was personally instructed by Bishop Christopher Saunders to make payments to potential victims.

Cherrille Quilty told The Pillar that from 2016 to 2017 she worked for Bishop Saunders, who led the Western Australia Diocese of Broome until 2021. 

Continue reading…

Why is Pope Francis embracing the patriarchy (of the West)?

(The Pillar).

Pope Francis has revived the papal title Patriarch of the West, bringing back the style which has fallen in and out of usage over the centuries and was most recently dropped by Benedict XVI in 2006.

In the 2024 edition of the Annuario Pontificio, the Vatican’s annual statistical yearbook, Patriarch of the West once again appears, in the litany of formal papal dignities listed at the opening. 

Continue reading…